Life of Fiction
Life of Fiction
S4 Episode #59: How Should Progression and Leveling Work
0:00
-20:55

S4 Episode #59: How Should Progression and Leveling Work

Leveling up isn’t just numbers—it’s identity, evolution, and earned transformation.

“Is becoming a hero about how much power you gain…
or how far you’ve come?”

In Episode 59 of Life of Fiction – the Podcast, we ask one of the biggest questions in RPG design: How should heroes grow?

From XP-driven advancement and story-based milestones to hybrid models and class trials, this episode explores how leveling systems can become powerful storytelling tools—not just stat spreadsheets.

Whether you’re into grinding monsters, earning narrative moments, or unlocking game-changing abilities through epic feats, this conversation challenges the traditional approach to character growth and invites you to help shape a system that makes leveling feel personal, meaningful, and unforgettable.

Here’s the exact article this podcast is connected to:

🎲 TTRPGs

The Hero Within RPG 12: How Should Progression and Leveling Work?

The Hero Within RPG 12: How Should Progression and Leveling Work?

Life of Fiction is a reader-supported publication. Get access to stories, art, videos, podcasts, games and more, by becoming a free or paid subscriber.

🧠 Key Takeaways from this Episode

🎚️ Progression = Purpose

In The Hero Within, leveling isn’t just about stats—it’s about storytelling.
Growth should feel like a shift in who your character is, not just what they can do.
This episode explores how leveling systems can align with personal arcs and narrative depth.


⚔️ XP vs. Milestones vs. Hybrid

The team dives into the three main systems of advancement:

  • XP-Based – Consistent and predictable, but risks turning growth into a grind.

  • Milestone-Based – Story-driven and emotional, but pacing can be uneven.

  • Hybrid – The best of both: XP for minor boosts, milestones for major evolution.

Each method changes how players interact with the world—and how their choices matter.


🌟 What Leveling Should Give You

Leveling in The Hero Within could offer:

  • Stat upgrades like Might, Coordination, and Reason

  • New skills, class abilities, or role-based powers

  • Unique story rewards, like titles, relationships, or faction influence

  • Special abilities tied to what your character has done, not just how much XP they’ve earned

Progression becomes part of the narrative arc, not just a mechanical routine.


🧪 Trials, Feats, and Heroic Moments

Not every level should come easy. The team discusses:

  • Class Trials – Advancement through challenges that fit your archetype

  • Epic Feats – Surviving legendary encounters, forging alliances, or changing the world

  • Narrative Milestones – Key story events that alter your character permanently

These systems encourage players to grow through story, not just combat.


⏳ Pacing and Shared Progress

The team also explores:

  • Group progression – Everyone levels together to keep story pacing clean

  • Pacing mechanics – Story arcs dictate growth rather than monster counts

  • Level caps and resets – Big class shifts (like becoming a Warlord or Magus) may “soft reset” character progression for balanced scaling

All of it is aimed at making growth feel earned, without bogging down the fun.


💬 Community Questions – Help Shape the System!

  • Should leveling be XP-driven, milestone-triggered, or a hybrid of both?

  • What’s the most exciting kind of reward to get when you level up?

  • Would you enjoy class trials or feat-based unlocks tied to your narrative?

  • How fast should characters grow in a story-focused system?

🛠️ Join the conversation at LifeOfFiction.com
Because your growth should be more than math—it should mean something.



Start the Adventure we’re all talking about…

Buy the Digital Version from Jaime!

Buy the Paperback Version from Amazon!

Join The Community & Grab Your Shirt!

If you love storytelling, role-playing games, or just being part of a creative movement, now is your chance.

Come play with me.

Remember: You are MORE than you THINK you are!
...see you next time. 🚀

jaime's signature

Let us know what you thought of the podcast, or if you have any questions, make sure to leave them in the comments or email podcast@lifeoffiction.com.


🔹 Life of Fiction is powered by readers like you! Get weekly stories, art, videos & Fiction HUB access. Subscribe free or go paid for exclusive perks!

Share Life of Fiction

Leave a comment

Discussion about this episode